John Robert Magaro (born February 16, 1983) is an American actor. He starred in the films Not Fade Away and First Cow. He also had supporting roles in Unbroken, The Big Short, Carol, Overlord and the Netflix series Orange Is the New Black and The Umbrella Academy. He made his Broadway debut as Earl Williams, the escaped convict, in the hit revival of The Front Page in 2016.
Known For
War Machine
(2017)
Cory Staggart
Unbroken
(2014)
Frank A. Tinker
Overlord
(2018)
Private First Class Lyle Tibbet
Past Lives
(2023)
Arthur
The Big Short
(2015)
Charlie Geller
The Many Saints of Newark
(2021)
Silvio Dante
The Finest Hours
(2016)
Ervin Maske
The Box
(2009)
Charles
Big George Foreman
(2023)
Desmond
Under the Boardwalk
(2023)
Manny (voice)
Carol
(2015)
Dannie McElroy
The Brave One
(2007)
Ethan
First Cow
(2019)
Cookie
Lansky
(2021)
Young Meyer Lansky
LaRoy, Texas
(2024)
Ray
Showing Up
(2022)
Sean
Full Filmography
Acting
The Brave One
(2007)
Ethan
The Life Before Her Eyes
(2007)
Michael Patrick
Bomb
(2007)
Assassination of a High School President
(2008)
Cipriato
The Box
(2009)
Charles
Taking Chance
(2009)
Rich Brewer
My Soul to Take
(2010)
Alex
Down the Shore
(2011)
Martin
Not Fade Away
(2012)
Douglas Damiano
Liberal Arts
(2012)
Dean
Deep Powder
(2013)
Cota
Unbroken
(2014)
Frank A. Tinker
Carol
(2015)
Dannie McElroy
The Big Short
(2015)
Charlie Geller
Don't Worry Baby
(2016)
Robert Lang
The Finest Hours
(2016)
Ervin Maske
War Machine
(2017)
Cory Staggart
Marshall
(2017)
Irwin Friedman
Overlord
(2018)
Private First Class Lyle Tibbet
First Cow
(2019)
Cookie
Sylvie's Love
(2020)
Sid
First Cow: A Place in This World
(2020)
Self
The Many Saints of Newark
(2021)
Silvio Dante
Lansky
(2021)
Young Meyer Lansky
The Birthday Cake
(2021)
Cousin Joey
18½
(2022)
Paul
Showing Up
(2022)
Sean
Call Jane
(2022)
Detective Chilmark
Past Lives
(2023)
Arthur
Big George Foreman
(2023)
Desmond
Day of the Fight
(2023)
The Mistress
(2023)
Parker
Under the Boardwalk
(2023)
Manny (voice)
LaRoy, Texas
(2024)
Ray
September 5
(2024)
The Bride!
(2025)
Crew
Production