Justin Hartley

Jacob Turner

Barrett Doss

Rachel Campbell

Bonnie Bedelia

Ellie Foster

Essence Atkins

Noel Hayden

James Remar

Scott Turner

Aaron Costa Ganis

Matt Segreto

Jeff Corbett

Ian Page

Andrea Sooch

Svetlana

Lucia Spina

Book Store Owner

Shelby Reitman Renee

Young Noel

Vivian Full

Shari

Mike Donovan

Alan

Whitney Kimball Long

Attractive Fan

Monica McCarthy

Lois Turner

Samantha Smart

Vamp Fan

Baylen Bielitz

Benjamin Turner

Gina D'Acciaro

Waitress

Lauren Yaffe

Fan

Alexander Blaise

Vittorio

Hollis Kempain Abram

Townsfolk

Blaine Morris

Nurse Cindy

Patrick K. Dooley

Todd

Marilyn Busch

Fifty-Something Fan

Kathleen Mary Carthy

Candlelight Inn Receptionist

William DeMeritt

Dion