Ben Johnson

Travis Blue

Joanne Dru

Denver

Harry Carey, Jr.

Sandy

Ward Bond

Elder Wiggs

Charles Kemper

Uncle Shiloh Clegg

Alan Mowbray

Dr. A. Locksley Hall

Jane Darwell

Sister Ledyard

Ruth Clifford

Fleuretty Phyffe

Russell Simpson

Adam Perkins

Kathleen O'Malley

Prudence Perkins

James Arness

Floyd Clegg

Francis Ford

Mr. Peachtree

Fred Libby

Reese Clegg

Jim Thorpe

Navajo Indian

Mickey Simpson

Jesse Clegg

Cliff Lyons

Marshal of Crystal City

Don Summers

Sam Jenkins

Movita

Young Navajo Indian

Hank Worden

Luke Clegg

Chuck Hayward

Jackson (uncredited)

Danny Borzage

Accordionist (uncredited)

Lee Bradley

Leader of the Navajo Band (uncredited)

Nora Bush

Settler (uncredited)

Jane Crowley

Settler (uncredited)

Tex Holden

Settler (uncredited)

George Huggins

Settler (uncredited)

Fred Kennedy

Settler (uncredited)

Al Kunde

Fiddler (uncredited)

Ann Kunde

Settler (uncredited)

Frank McGrath

Posse Member (uncredited)

Evelyn Moriarty

Settler (uncredited)

Eleanore Vogel

Settler (uncredited)