Dan Stevens

Noah

John Travolta

Eddie

Michael Pitt

Zach

Jackie Earle Haley

Gerry

Travis Aaron Wade

Agent Santos

Christopher Abbott

Warren

Rob Brown

Bryce

Edi Gathegi

Marques

Morgan Wolk

Janie

Alan B. Jones

Agent Reichert

Chris Haley

Matthew

Christopher Jay Gresham

Little Mike

Bobby C. King

Agent Colin

Tyrone Jenkins

Demetrius

Rex Baker

Orpheus

Stan Van Pelt

Julian

Don Robert Cass

Pastor

Jerry Lee Tucker

Private Investigator

Deidre Harmon

Paula

Kenny Santiago Marrero

Renaldo

Aric Floyd

Kid-William Harrison

Ananias Dixon

Tyrone Flemmings

Nick Loren

Mechanic

Lisa Catara

Waitress

Joe Fishel

Club Patron

Gary A. Jones

Whitney Patron (uncredited)

Chris Hahn

Bodyguard (uncredited)

Austin Elkins

Young Gerry