Ray Milland

Eric Yeager

Jan Sterling

Polly Sickles

Gene Lockhart

Thaddeus J. Banner

William Frawley

Len Sickles

Elsie Holmes

Myra Banner

Taylor Holmes

P. Duncan Munk

Willard Waterman

Orlando Dill

Henry Slate

Dud Logan

James Griffith

Ogelthorpe Meadows

Jim Hayward

Doom

Donald MacBride

Pheeny

Hal K. Dawson

Mr. Fisher

Brooks Benedict

Dill's Lawyer #1 (uncredited)

Edward Biby

Weather Forecaster (uncredited)

Billie Bird

Mona Lizzie (uncredited)

Larry J. Blake

Police Radio Voice (uncredited) (voice)

Madge Blake

Mrs. Emily Thompson (uncredited)

Oliver Blake

Cadaver Jones (uncredited)

Gail Bonney

Woman with Dog (uncredited)

Joe Brooks

Courtroom Spectator (uncredited)

Morgan Brown

Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited)

Harry Cheshire

Mr. Seegle - Board Member (uncredited)

Edward Clark

Judge Loudermilk (uncredited)

Tris Coffin

Dr. Henry J. Stillman (uncredited)

Paul Douglas

Man on Park Bench (uncredited)

Jimmie Dundee

Pencil Louie's Driver (uncredited)

Al Ferguson

Policeman in Garden (uncredited)

James Flavin

O'Leary, Manhattan Police Chief (uncredited)

Adda Gleason

Maid (uncredited)

Sandra Gould

Housewife Bettor (uncredited)

Joe Gray

Baseball Player (uncredited)

Mack Gray

Suspect in Polo Coat in Line-Up (uncredited)

Don Haggerty

Policeman (uncredited)

Chuck Hamilton

Detective (uncredited)

Stuart Holmes

Golfer (uncredited)

Wilbur Mack

Golfer (uncredited)

George Magrill

Policeman at Ballpark (uncredited)

Strother Martin

Michael 'Shorty' McGirk (uncredited)

Edwin Max

Fish Eye (uncredited)

Howard Negley

Process Server (uncredited)

Leonard Nimoy

Young Baseball Player (uncredited)

Jack Perry

Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited)

Joe Ploski

Henchman (uncredited)

Ralph Sanford

Eddie - Brooklyn Police Chief (uncredited)

Charles Sherlock

Court Clerk (uncredited)

Bert Stevens

Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited)

Jack Stoney

Henchman (uncredited)

Frank Sully

Big Head Charlie - Bookie (uncredited)

Dorothy Vernon

Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited)

Sailor Vincent

Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited)

Ben Welden

Oily Moe - Bookie (uncredited)

Orangey

Rhubarb (uncredited; one of 14 cats in the role)