Drew Starkey

Rodney

Aaron Domínguez

Luis

Isaiah Stratton

Det Randall Wycliffe

Gary Weeks

Det. Bob Simpson

Pat Dortch

Tearlach O'Rian

Javon Johnson

Jackie Founders

Jackie Goldston

Sally O'Leary

Michael Aaron Milligan

Henry

Ezekiel Ajeigbe

Lamar Boyd

Josh Murray

The Dark Stranger

Lacy Camp

Kathleen Simpson

Pierce Pope

Young Tearlach O'Rian

Patrick G. Keenan

Killian O'Leary

Andrew Hunter

Alex

Johanna Jowett

Joanna O'Day

Erin Dangler

Julie Devine

Paxton Pope

Younger Tearlach O'Rian

Jason Wesley

Robert Hernandez

Brett Baker

Father of the Bride

Alison Maccherone Gomez

Bookstore Customer

Beth Felice

Todd's Mother

Christina Leidel

Mara O'Rian

Suzie Haines

Shoplifter

Kyle Riggs

Todd Jacobs

Amanda Medina

Party goer

Karen Wheeling Reynolds

Baker

Austin Hutchinson

Josh Cooper

Jonathan Bedford

Aodan O'Rian

Alex Phipps

Ricky Jenkins

Jake Collison

Dylan Lighthall

Young Detective

Paul Stober

Dennis

Sloan Stewart

Tonya Richards

Daniel Campos

Lyndsey Duffield

Sarah Lewis

Taylor Barnes

Small Bodyguard

Mark Hayes

Big Bodyguard

Sheridan Plunkett

O'Days Waitress

Krystal Foggie Gardner

Club goer (uncredited)